Have you ever thought, “I burn 500 calories per workout—why am I not losing weight?” Every day, I see people eagerly starting their smartwatches to track their training sessions, particularly to measure calorie burn. Unfortunately, research has shown that these devices are not as accurate as you might think.
The Problem with Smartwatch Calorie Estimates
While fitness trackers can be great for motivation, monitoring activity levels, and training at certain intensities, they often overestimate calorie burn—sometimes by hundreds of calories per day. This discrepancy can lead to frustration, confusion, and unrealistic expectations about how much you should eat or burn.
What the Research Says
Studies suggest that smartwatches and fitness trackers are unreliable for measuring calorie expenditure. Research from Stanford Medicine found that while many devices can track heart rates with reasonable accuracy, their calorie burn estimates often vary significantly from actual energy expenditure.
Additionally, a study published in PubMed examined the effectiveness of popular fitness trackers and found that their calorie calculations were inconsistent during moderate-intensity exercise. These inaccuracies could lead users to overestimate their energy expenditure and make poor dietary or fitness decisions.
Further research, such as findings shared by Barpath Fitness, indicates that some fitness trackers may have error rates ranging between 27% and 93% when estimating calories burned. This significant margin of error highlights the need for users to interpret these numbers cautiously and avoid relying on them as precise measurements.
These findings reinforce the importance of viewing calorie burn data from fitness trackers as an estimate rather than an exact calculation. Instead of focusing on individual numbers, it is best to track progress over time and make adjustments based on actual results.
A Better Approach to Managing Weight
Rather than trusting your smartwatch’s calorie estimates unquestioningly, try these strategies for more accurate progress tracking:
-
Track Trends, Not Single-Day Numbers – Don’t focus on daily fluctuations, as weight can change by a couple of pounds from day to day. Instead, observe long-term trends.
-
Control Both Sides of the Equation – Managing weight comes down to balancing energy intake versus energy expenditure. Ensure you’re accurately tracking both your food intake and activity levels.
-
Stay Consistent – If you’re not losing weight, you’re not in a deficit—regardless of what your watch says.
The Best Measure of a Caloric Deficit
The safest and most reliable way to determine if you’re in a calorie deficit isn’t through your smartwatch—it’s through real-world results. If you’re not losing weight over time, adjust your intake or activity accordingly.
Remember, technology is a tool meant to assist you, but it comes with variability in results. Instead, focus on staying consistent with good training, nutrition, and lifestyle strategies—results will follow.
Yours In Fitness,
CSCS | CFL3 | Fitness Specialist | Biomechanics Specialist | USAWL1
“Take care of your body. It’s the only place you have to live.”
Owner/Head Coach – Black Flag Athletics